A Man Buys a $4 Painting and Finds an Invaluable Treasure Behind the Frame
An Ordinary Flea Market
A casual visit to a flea market: On an unassuming day in Adamstown, Pennsylvania, a man who wished to keep his identity a secret, wandered through the crowded aisles of a local flea market. Like countless others, he was drawn to the allure of finding hidden treasures.
The buzz of bargaining and the sounds of the sellers faded into the background as he roamed, never suspecting that this ordinary shopping trip would turn into a story worth telling.
Not His First Rodeo
A collector's curious find: Among the numerous flea market enthusiasts, there was a buyer with a penchant for antiques, particularly antique stocks, bonds, and a variety of paper collectibles.
His experienced eyes were tuned to spot potential treasures. In 1989, his seemingly routine treasure hunt took a turn when he stumbled upon an artifact that promised to change his world of collecting.
A Framed Object
The enticing frame: The bustling market offered countless items vying for attention, but a particularly weathered painting caught the buyer's eye. Not because of the art, but because of the antique wooden frame that surrounded it.
Without hesitation, and with the seasoned ease of an experienced buyer, he exchanged a mere four dollars for the artwork, unaware that he was on the verge of discovering something monumental.
Landscape Scene
Removing the facade: The artwork, depicting a peaceful landscape, showed clear signs of age, its canvas marked with wear. For the mysterious buyer...
The painting itself was inconsequential, a mere veil hiding the potential treasures of the frame. Searching for the secrets of the frame, the painting was discarded, consigned to oblivion.
A Piece of Paper Within
Unveiling a mystery: As the discarded painting lay abandoned, the buyer carefully freed the frame from its contents. Behind the canvas lay a seemingly unremarkable piece of linen paper...
With dimensions of 15.5 by 19.75 inches, the paper appeared unassuming. But upon closer inspection, a wave of familiarity washed over the buyer, indicating potential historical significance.
Enclosed
Collecting often leads to discovering hidden treasures with unique stories and narratives. The buyer had always found joy in such discoveries, immersing himself in the stories behind each find. But this relic was more than just another addition to his collection; it surpassed all previous findings.
The magnitude of its historical significance resonated deeply within him, sending waves of awe through his veins. He wasted no time in securing it away, guarding its secrets for the time being.
The Declaration of Independence
A document from the past: Within the secure space of the buyer, resided nothing less than a copy of the historic Declaration of Independence from 1776.
Before the cinematic adventures of Nicholas Cage could come to fruition, this genuine national treasure was safely hidden in the buyer's possession, awaiting its future.
Contacting Sotheby's
The journey to authenticate a potential historical piece is a mixture of fear and anticipation. This document was not just any document; it symbolized a turning point in history. Yet paradoxically, it lay inconspicuously in a corner of his house for months, surrounded by everyday life.
It was only the repeated urging of a familiar friend, who recognized the potential significance of the document, that prompted the buyer to seek an evaluation from the renowned auction house, Sotheby's.
Professional Skepticism
Sotheby's and its fame: Sotheby's is unrivaled in the field of art, jewelry, and collectibles, synonymous with auctioning timeless treasures.
Entrusting them with this potentially priceless document was a natural choice for the buyer. However, Sotheby's initial reactions were marked by skepticism.
Countless False Claims
Selby Kiffer, the esteemed Vice President of Sotheby's Department of Books and Manuscripts, provided insight into the world of artifact authentication, speaking of the initial skepticism surrounding claims of an original copy of the Declaration of Independence.
These stories often ended, regardless of how captivating or heartfelt they were, in the sobering realization that the artifact in question was merely a reproduction. Such experiences with forgeries had instilled a natural caution in the experts at Sotheby's.
Numerous Reproductions
The world of historical artifacts is rife with misunderstandings, and many so-called treasures are actually convincing reproductions of the revered document, complete with the 56 iconic signatures.
These replicas have appeared over time in various locations. Their ubiquitous existence often led to premature excitement, which upon closer inspection proved unfounded. Kiffer's insights served as a timely reminder to approach such discoveries with a mix of optimism and caution.
The Real Deal
Authenticating historical artifacts can often be a daunting task, filled with skepticism and doubt. Here, this yellowed parchment, at the center of heated debates and speculations, was no exception.
As they delved deeper, the signs became promising, and a carefully engraved seal confirmed the document's authenticity. This seal served as indisputable evidence of the parchment's historical origin.
The Exact Date
The seal of authenticity: An indelible marking on the back of the document proclaimed its identity - Declaration of American Independence. July 4, 1776.
This revelation sent waves of disbelief through the buyer. Such a central artifact of history surely belonged in a museum, not hidden behind an old painting.
Spreading the Word
A relic of celebration: Following the historic declaration of American independence, John Dunlap, a printer from Philadelphia, was tasked with spreading this joyful message.
Expert Peter Planes took viewers on a captivating journey, intertwining David's personal story with the details of the Rolex, all in search of its true market value. This combination of historical insight, personal connection, and expert analysis turned an ordinary appraisal into a viral phenomenon.
A Key Piece of History
The significance of the copy: Despite the term "copy," the importance of the document was immense. David Redden, Vice Chairman of Sotheby's, speculated that only around 200 of these original replicas were made.
They were distributed among the influential leaders of the era, the military forces, and the emerging 13 colonies, marking an indelible chapter in history.
Amazing Condition
The buyer who had discovered a document believed to be one of only 24 surviving copies from its time had an unexpected treasure in his hands. The painting he had acquired for a mere $4 was in less than perfect condition, but the document hidden behind it remained in impeccable condition. David Redden, Vice Chairman of Sotheby's, was surprised by its extraordinary preservation.
Here was the most important single printed page in the world, in spectacularly beautiful condition," he marveled, emphasizing the rarity and significance of such a discovery in a market scenario.
Millions and Millions
As another original copy had already been auctioned off in January 1990 for $1.59 million, many speculated that this newly discovered gem could fetch a value between $800,000 and $1.2 million.
But contrary to all expectations and in the light of the unpredictable nature of the auction world, this particular document sold for an astonishing $8.1 million. The stunning price further underscored the incredible luck and destiny that the buyer had experienced in his flea market adventure.
A Lucky Find
The big question was: How could such a precious 18th-century document end up at a flea market in Adamstown? It was a puzzle that many pondered, yet the origins remained a mystery.
Selby Kiffer, familiar with the history, reflected on the document's unusual journey. It must be called a lucky find," he mused, noting how improbable such discoveries are.
Inspiring Other Treasure Hunters
Selby Kiffer believed that stories of such lucky finds, especially those that are lucrative, would undoubtedly trigger a rush to flea markets. He anticipated renewed interest from treasure hunters and hobbyists eager to discover hidden gems.
This could inspire many people to scour flea market stalls," he remarked. And he was not alone in this opinion; enthusiasts of shows like Antiques Roadshow have long supported the potential of such explorations.
Too Much to Process
Over the years, Antiques Roadshow has had its fair share of surprised participants, and David, a veteran of the Air Force, was no exception. With an old watch, a heirloom he had owned for almost half a century, he turned to the experts of the show.
He had no idea that the watch's story and value would shock him. Witnesses said David's knees buckled when the appraisal was revealed, and it seemed like he was about to faint from the overwhelming revelation.
A Hard Life
David's life was not marked by wealth or luxury. His younger years were defined by being drafted during the Vietnam War, a time when the fate of young men was determined by lottery numbers.
When David's number inevitably came up, he faced a clear choice: join an Army unit or be automatically drafted. His decision led him to the U.S. Air Force, where he took on the dangerous job of disposing explosive ordnance.
Vietnam Veteran
David's role in the military was perilous. He was tasked with removing landmines from roads and encountering hazards in compromised ammunition depots.
In an episode of Antiques Roadshow in January 2020, he talked about the tragedies of that time. Many children and adults were injured by unexploded ordnance, he solemnly recalled.
Incredible Danger
In 1973, David was stationed in Thailand for two years. His duties often took him aboard Continental Airlines, where he observed a pattern among the pilots.
Many of them wore Rolex watches, a brand that David soon fell in love with. This sparked a fascination and desire to own one of these luxurious timepieces.
Stint in Thailand
Despite his newfound fascination, David soon realized a harsh reality: Rolexes were expensive, and one was definitely beyond his budget. But fate had a hand in the game when David was transferred to a new base where he took up diving.
Rolex, known for its robust dive watches, called out to David once again. The allure was irresistible, and the brand dominated his thoughts once more.
Dreaming of Rolex
After careful consideration, David purchased a Rolex at what he found to be a fair price of $345.97 after a 10% discount. This amount was almost equivalent to a month's salary in the 1970s military; it was a considerable luxury.
The watch was ordered through the base department store in November 1974. But the excitement was tempered with patience as David had to wait until April of the following year for its arrival.
A Reasonable Option
In search of a quality timepiece, David carefully chose the Rolex Oyster Cosmograph, fascinated by its craftsmanship and heritage. But when the exquisite watch finally lay in his hands, he found himself facing a dilemma he had not anticipated.
Fearing possible damage, he made a conscious decision. Instead of integrating it into his daily life, he chose to keep it stored in a deposit box where it would be protected from the elements and the passage of time.
The Rolex Oyster Cosmograph
Over the course of 30 to 40 years, the Rolex was only taken out of its secure case two or three times. Each time, it was admired, treated with the utmost care, and then safely stored again.
Its impeccable condition, combined with David's decision to keep all the original documents, ensured that the watch retained its value over the years.
Great Condition
David's careful preservation of the Rolex in such a pristine condition naturally piqued his curiosity about its potential value in the current market. To get an expert opinion on its worth, he turned to the trusted appraisers of Antiques Roadshow.
The series, known for its precise evaluations, seemed to be the ideal platform to reveal the hidden value of David's timepiece.
Curious about Value
While the American version of Antiques Roadshow enjoyed considerable success, its origins can be traced back to the United Kingdom. The original concept originated as a BBC documentary that followed London auctioneers on their travels through the West of England.
Its premiere on May 17, 1977, was an immediate hit and cemented the format of the show, which has changed very little to this day.
Decades of Discoveries
Interestingly, the US version of Antiques Roadshow, despite its fame, is an adaptation of its British predecessor. The original version was conceived as a BBC documentary. In this show, viewers followed auctioneers from London on their journey through the West of England.
Its premiere on May 17, 1977, was overwhelmingly well-received. The format, a hit with the audience, remained consistent in its subsequent iterations, showcasing the timeless appeal of the search for hidden treasures.
An Episode like No Other
The British heritage of 'Antiques Roadshow': Antiques Roadshow, with its origins in the United Kingdom, can boast an impressive legacy of over 40 unique series. The long-running show has always been under the banner of the BBC. Over the years, several spin-offs have been created.
One notable spin-off is Antiques Roadshow: The Next Generation, which ran every Christmas from 1991 to 2006 and specifically targeted a younger audience. Another variation of the show's format was the 20th Century Roadshow, which aired briefly in 2005. Despite these variations, the charm and essence of the original show have largely remained intact.
Follow-up
America's interpretation of Antiques Roadshow: The immense popularity of the original British Antiques Roadshow eventually reached America. Inspired by the British version, the show Antiques Roadshow FYI aired in America in 2005.
This half-hour segment provided a deeper insight into the world of antiques and gave viewers a more comprehensive understanding of collectibles. Additionally, this version revisited items previously featured on the main series, informing viewers about their further development.
High Price Tags
Decades of extraordinary discoveries: What makes Antiques Roadshow particularly captivating are the amazing treasures discovered throughout the show's run. Both the British and US versions have presented incredibly valuable artifacts.
A notable example is an original sketch of Antony Gormley's sculpture "Angel of the North," now an iconic symbol of northern England. When it appeared on the UK version in 2008, the sketch was estimated to be worth an astounding $1.29 million, showcasing the immense value hidden in seemingly ordinary objects.
Millions of Dollars
Highly valued artworks in the US: In the US version of the show, many artworks have garnered attention and high evaluations. One notable appraisal was for a painting from 1904 by renowned Mexican artist Diego Rivera.
Originally valued between $800,000 and $1 million in 2012, the artwork's value increased six years later to an estimated $1.2 to $2.2 million due to the growing demand for Rivera's works.
Chinese Cups
A variety of valuable antiques: The appeal of Antiques Roadshow extends beyond highly valued artwork. The show has revealed a range of priceless antiques throughout its broadcasts.
In addition, artworks by prominent American artists such as Andrew Wyeth and Norman Rockwell were each estimated to be worth around half a million dollars, showcasing the diverse array of objects the show presents.
Nationwide
The US Antiques Roadshow's nationwide tour: The US version of Antiques Roadshow, presented by PBS, follows a traveling format, visiting various locations across the country.
This approach allows the show to explore both prominent cities and lesser-known places, uncovering unique antiques and stories. The selection of these cities brings forth diverse narratives and treasures from different corners of the nation.
Bonanzaville
A visit to Bonanzaville: In January 2020, the Antiques Roadshow team traveled to Bonanzaville, a fascinating museum complex in West Fargo, North Dakota.
Consisting of 40 historical and contemporary buildings, this complex provides a vibrant depiction of various eras. Against this backdrop, David, the Air Force veteran, saw the opportunity to have his cherished Rolex appraised.
Chinese Cups
A variety of valuable antiques: The appeal of Antiques Roadshow extends beyond highly valued artwork. The show has revealed a range of priceless antiques throughout its broadcasts.
In addition, artworks by prominent American artists such as Andrew Wyeth and Norman Rockwell were each estimated to be worth around half a million dollars, showcasing the diverse array of objects the show presents.
Nationwide
The US Antiques Roadshow's nationwide tour: The US version of Antiques Roadshow, presented by PBS, follows a traveling format, visiting various locations across the country.
This approach allows the show to explore both prominent cities and lesser-known places, uncovering unique antiques and stories. The selection of these cities brings forth diverse narratives and treasures from different corners of the nation.
Bonanzaville
A visit to Bonanzaville: In January 2020, the Antiques Roadshow team made their way to Bonanzaville, a fascinating museum complex in West Fargo, North Dakota.
Comprising of 40 historical and contemporary buildings, this complex provides a vibrant depiction of different eras. Against this backdrop, David, an Air Force veteran, saw the opportunity to have his cherished Rolex appraised.
David's Appearance
The appraisal segment featuring David's Rolex quickly became a digital phenomenon, capturing the attention of watch enthusiasts and casual viewers alike.
After being uploaded to the dedicated Antiques Roadshow YouTube channel, it didn't take long for the video to amass an impressive 7.5 million views, solidifying its place as a standout moment in the show's rich appraisal history.
Meticulous Documentation
The importance of documentation: Planes meticulously examines the papers that David has kept with the Rolex. This includes brochures, receipts, and, most importantly, the original warranty paper.
Due to its pristine condition, which can significantly increase the value of a watch, Planes estimates the warranty paper alone to be worth around $2,000.
A Special Variation
In the intricate world of horology, where every detail counts, Planes showcases his expertise by focusing on the unique features of David's Rolex.
These features are not just ornamental, but rather marks of distinction that demonstrate the uniqueness of the watch. This nuance, which Planes effortlessly recognizes, further underscores the immense value and rarity of David's timepiece.
Two Styles
The intricacies of the Rolex's design are not just aesthetically pleasing but also functionally innovative. Among the offerings of this iconic watch, two styles were prominent. But what truly set a style apart were the screw-down crowns.
In an era where such a feature was a novelty, this particular attribute significantly enhanced the watch's appeal. For enthusiasts and global buyers, the combination of style and groundbreaking utility in this Rolex was particularly coveted.
Mint Condition
Assessing the watch's condition: The flawless condition of the watch does not escape Planes' notice. He observes the presence of a sticker on the back of the Rolex.
The sticker, typically the first thing to wear off, indicates the pristine condition of the watch. Additionally, Planes identifies the date inscription, revealing the production year of the watch as 1971.
Influence of Film Stars
The connection to Paul Newman: Planes further explains why collectors hold this Rolex model in high esteem. The model gained immense popularity thanks to Hollywood icon Paul Newman.
After the actor wore the watch in the 1969 film "Winning," his subsequent passion for motorsports and the association of the Rolex with his racing image made the watch an emblem of coolness.
Radiating Coolness
The cultural impact of the Daytona Rolex: The cultural significance of Rolex was emphasized by journalist Travis Andrews of The Washington Post in 2017. Andrews wrote about the mechanical watch and its owner, Newman, both exuding coolness.
This cultural attraction reached its peak in 2017 when Paul Newman's personal Daytona Rolex was auctioned for an astonishing $17.8 million.
Six Figures
David's moment of truth: During the appraisal, Planes informs David about the typical auction values of the Daytona Rolex, ranging between $150,000 and $200,000.
David, despite the astounding figure, maintains composure and patiently waits for Planes' final verdict. However, the subsequent revelation from Planes elicits an unexpected and profound reaction from David.
Short Production Period
Planes has a moment of revelation as he examines David's watch. This particular variation, called "Oyster," was in production for only a brief period of time. It is even more distinctive than the iconic model worn by Newman.
Planes identifies it as a Mark Two Dial. The rare Oyster labeling makes this watch highly coveted. In an auction, such a model would fetch an astounding price, with an estimated value of around $400,000 according to Planes.
Significant Reaction
The magnitude of the revelation is so profound that it physically manifests in David. Planes rushes to David to ensure he is okay, as his reaction has surprised everyone, emphasizing that the well-being of the veteran is of utmost importance.
Meanwhile, the atmosphere in the room transforms; a chorus of laughter off-camera echoes, bearing witness to the sheer unexpectedness of David's reaction. This collective amusement underscores a moment that goes beyond just an appraisal—it is a human experience of joy, shock, and overwhelming surprise.
No Harm Done
To everyone's relief, David shows resilience and laughs incredulously at the number he just heard. However, Planes advises David to remain calm, as there is more to the story.
He explains that he deliberately chose his words when he mentioned that a watch like David's would be valued at $400,000.
Even More Valuable
Planes further reveals that David's watch exceeds the previous valuation due to its flawless condition. It's a new old stock watch, no wear on it at all, and... we have this complete documentation, he notes.
This, combined with the rarity of finding such a watch in unworn condition, exponentially increases its value. Then, Planes drops a bombshell: the estimated auction value for David's unique piece ranges between an astonishing $500,000 and $700,000.
Blown Away
During the revelation, David, perhaps due to his military discipline, remains steadfast. His astonishment, palpable and almost tangible, culminates in a comment that erupts from pure, unfiltered wonder.
This unscripted and profoundly human moment contrasts sharply with Planes' professional demeanor. The appraiser remains resolute in his judgment, with a hint of confident calmness.
Absolutely Fabulous"
Planes informs David of how monumental this find is. He describes it as one of the rarest Paul Newman models and emphasizes that due to its condition, it may be the best example ever.
In his eyes, the watch is one of the most extraordinary pieces ever shown on Antiques Roadshow. He expresses his gratitude to David not only for presenting such an artifact but also for his military service.
Future Plans
With such a significant find comes certain responsibilities. Planes advises David against wearing this magnificent piece as it could decrease its value to the previously mentioned $400,000.
While David's intentions for the watch remain a mystery, in an interview with The Washington Post, Planes speculates that David may be more inclined to preserve it, highlighting David's historical inclination towards conservation.
The Most Expensive Watch
Planes has witnessed many guest reactions during his time on the show. However, David's reaction, full of incredulous amazement, remains one of the most moving and unforgettable moments in his memory.
In the annals of the show's rich history, another majestic watch remains unrivaled. With a stunning estimated value between $2 and $3 million, this watch stands unsurpassed in both its financial worth and significance.
David's Fans
David's extraordinary story quickly captivated audiences worldwide. The video clip from Antiques Roadshow has garnered millions of views and numerous comments on YouTube.
The majority of these online interactions express pure joy and happiness for David, as one user commented: "Someone's retirement just got a lot more comfortable. Congratulations to this gentleman."
Big Congratulations
The heartwarming sentiment continues. Other viewers express their admiration for David's military service and how deserving he is of this sudden windfall.
The man spent his time in service defusing mines and unexploded ordnance. I couldn't think of a more deserving person for this kind of discovery. Hats off!
Some Opposition
Despite many positive reactions, there has also been skepticism and criticism of Planes' appraisal, especially regarding the condition of the watch.
These critics quickly pointed out visible signs of wear on the bracelet and even identified a subtle scratch on the front of the watch. Such observations stood in stark contrast to Planes' confident explanation of the watch as unworn old stock.
Not Quite Brand New
A particular point of contention among the critics was the condition of the sticker and clasp of the watch. Some argued that these components would show signs of years of use.
This perceived inconsistency led some to label Planes' appraisal as unprofessional and even describe it as "amateurish." This sparked a growing debate among the watch community and viewers.
Another Expert
Paul Boutros, a recognized authority in the field of watches, stepped in to confirm the appraisal. He emphasized the watch's exceptional preservation condition and its comprehensive authenticity, making it a highly sought-after piece.
To further illustrate the feasibility of such an appraisal, he drew parallels to a comparable watch that achieved an impressive $425,000 at an auction in December 2019. This not only bolstered the credibility of Planes' estimation but also showcased the immense value and desirability of such rare, well-preserved artifacts.
Great Gains
The enormous discrepancy between the original $345.97 David spent on the watch and its current valuation is even more astounding considering these numbers.
Such a phenomenal return on investment underscores why David's reaction was instinctual. It's not just about the monetary value; it is a testament to the captivating surprises that keep fans tuning in to Antiques Roadshow.
Comments
0 comment